Sylvia and I moved to Winnipeg in August 1970. As we were settling in and
getting to know the Jewish community, we quickly became aware of the
differences from what we were familiar with in the USA. Winnipeg Jews around
our age often seemed “old-fashioned,” we said. Their values and sometimes even
their way of speaking was more like our parents. We soon realized why: whereas
our parents and sometimes even grandparents were second generation immigrants;
in Winnipeg our peers were second, and in some cases, even the first generation –
hence they were closer to the “old country.”
Realizing this explained the more traditional values we found here.
Accordingly, the many synagogues were mainly Orthodox, with only two
Conservative – leaving all but one, Reform, that being Temple Shalom. At the time
it didn’t have a permanent place of worship, so the congregants moved around the
city with a portable Ark – like Jews in the desert after the Exodus.
That was over half-a-century ago, and much has changed. Not only does
Temple Shalom have a permanent home, but the values of the other synagogues –
in particular, the two Conservative shuls – have changed, becoming more
progressive in many ways. Specifically, Shaarey Zedek has gradually “reformed”
its rules, most importantly regarding the role of women in ritual life, along with
membership on the executive and such. All this was probably inevitable, for they
were just following what was happening in the secular society at large, more than
trying to copy Temple Shalom.
Nonetheless, this process meant that these two shuls kept getting closer and
closer, so that today the differences are few. Perhaps our Temple is still more
progressive in terms of the attitudes toward the LGBTQ+ community – but I’m
sure, in time, that difference will disappear too.
Thus, what’s left?  Before July 8, I would have said “not much.”
But on that day something popped up on my computer to bring this topic
right before my eyes. On Tuesday, July 8, the on-line, Winnipeg Jewish
Review, reported that Shaarey Zedek had opened a new Children’s Centre. I’m not

going to name names, since that’s irrelevant to my story. But when the Review
mentioned the members of the extended family of the donor (with pictures), I came
across a phrase that jumped off my computer screen.
To put this into context, here’s a brief back-story. Years ago, Rabbi Bill
Tepper and I had a chat about Jewish conversion. In the course of our discussion, I
told him what a Reform rabbi once said to me many years ago. “If anyone converts
in Orthodox or Conservative synagogues, they will be treated with love and respect
– but they will always be a convert. In Reform, however, one is integrated into the
community and the topic should never be mentioned again, unless the person wants
to self-disclose.” Rabbi Bill agreed with this, and thought it was a good way of
putting forth the Reform position.
Back to July 8 and the article about the donor’s family. In the course of
quoting from the speech at the ceremony, it concluded by naming all the people in
the picture of the large extended family – and at the end, as it came to the final
faces in the crowd, it said they were “Jews by choice.”
“Ah ha!” I said to my computer. “Shaarey Zedek is still different.”